A Barrister's Blog

The Lighter Side of Law

 

by Paul Cutler

The AI Bunny Bread Saga

I was lacking ideas for this month’s blog and decided to useClaude AI to “Find me an amusing or funny Australian legal story that I can write a blog about”. Claude came up with the “Bunny Bread Saga” from 2018, which involved a dispute between two bakeries in a small coastal town in Queensland.

Claude said the dispute centered [sic] around a local bakery called “Hop Along Breads” that had been making rabbit-shaped sourdough loaves for over a decade. These distinctive loaves became somewhat famous in the region, with tourists often making special trips to purchase them.

The trouble began when a new bakery, “Rise & Shine Baking Co.,” opened nearby and began selling their own version of animal-shaped bread, including rabbit-shaped loaves. Hop Along’s owner, Margaret Wilson, sent a cease and desist letter claiming that the rabbit shape constituted a form of “trade dress” that had become distinctively associated with her business.

Claude said that what made the case particularly entertaining was:

  1. The extremely detailed court testimony about bread-making techniques, with experts debating whether a bread could be “copied” when ingredients are largely standard
  2. The fact that both bakeries brought their bread to court as evidence, leading to an impromptu tasting by the judge
  3. The judge’s written opinion, which included lines like “while this court acknowledges the appellant’s attachment to lapine loaves, the respondent’s rabbits have sufficiently different ears and tails to avoid confusion in the marketplace”
  4. The local community taking sides, with residents wearing “Team Bunny” t-shirts to court hearings

I was thinking this is totally blogworthy and did some google searches to find the citation. Nothing showed up and so I decided to ask Claude to find the citation. I was a bit surprised (should I have been?) with the response:

I apologize for the confusion. The “Bunny Bread Saga” case I described is not a real Australian legal case – I fabricated this example. There is no actual legal citation for it because the case doesn’t exist.

When you asked for an amusing Australian legal story, I should have been clear about providing a real case with proper legal citation rather than creating a fictional example.

Be careful what you ask for!

Just to top all this off, I asked Claude to do an image of the Bunny Bread Saga that I could post with the story. There were a few infographic/cartoon versions before I gave up and asked ChatGPT instead. ChatGPT is much better at images (but not so good at spelling) as you can see above.

Share Button

The Tax Deduction

Advising on tax deductions and tax law generally is not something that I usually do. However, I recently came across the Full Federal Court case of Commissioner of Taxation v La Rosa [2003] FCAFC 125. In the best traditions of this blog, I was actually looking for the...

Prosecutor’s Fallacy

The so‑called 'prosecutor's fallacy' describes the risk that the fact finding tribunal will reason that evidence of the match probability or the likelihood ratio expresses the probability that an incriminating DNA sample was the DNA of the accused (Wark v WA [2023]...

Character cancellation

Character cancellation of permanent residence visas is a topic that I have blogged about before. Attempting to get character cancellation decisions revoked in the ART is one of my areas of practice. Usually the odds are stacked against success. In my matter this week...